Muthead

Back to Eli Manning

Single thread,
bigbodypaulwaul
-12 points

In the postseason the defense was cold. Locked up Favre in the nfc championship and bailed Eli out. Also we’re cold in 2011 nfc championship game

honeybaker100
11 points

So I’m guessing the defense made that deep ball pass to Mario manningham down the sideline

bigbodypaulwaul
-2 points

That was good but the helmet catch was 100% luck

Steelersfan930

I hate people who say it was luck cause its not. Google definition of Luck: Success or failure apparently brought by chance rather than through one's own actions. Do take a moment to note the last part of that definition, and then explain to me how David Tyree catching the ball against his own head was NOT a success brought on by his own actions. If Tyree didn't catch the ball, WHO THE FUCK DID?! All credit goes to Drew Magary. Source: https://www.google.com/amp/s/deadspin.com/dear-bill-simmons-the-helmet-catch-was-not-luck-5855985/amp

randysavage1992
5 points

He had 0 HOF consideration receivers Plaxico had between 8k-9k career receiving yards with only 60-70 TDs I don’t understand your argument? Defeated the GOAT x2 in a Super Bowl. Tom Brady had Randy Moss arguably the greatest WR of all time. (Rice was the greatest). And the Patriots defense was LIT with Vrabel and Bruschi.

bassmaster14609
1 point

Rice had the better career but anyone who has ever watched Football knows Moss is the greatest WR talent to ever catch a ball

randysavage1992

Definitely on deep balls. If it was a short route though Rice was who you wanted. His numbers imo declare him the greatest.

bigbodypaulwaul

The same can be said about the 2017 eagles 2015 broncos 2013 Seahawks 0 hof receivers

randysavage1992
1 point

But Demaryius Thomas just got a legend card. And the Philly special was a play determined An illegal formation after the Super Bowl? Both of which are in the game. How was he carried? Couldn’t you say that Brady was carried by Vinateri? Because without him they don’t win those games in the 2000s.

bigbodypaulwaul
1 point

Brady and Eli both got carried imo. Peyton better than both

randysavage1992
1 point

Regular season Peyton yes. And Peyton is definitely better than Eli not even a contest.