Yes and no. Skill based passing to me is all about "covered" receivers and being able to dot the ball exactly where you want it to make a previously contested ball catchable. I agree that this should be user input / skill driven, and classic passing shouldn't mimic this ability.
HOWEVER, to the point of this post, whether it's classic passing or skill passing, hitting a wide open receiver or an RB on a check down should have zero percent correlation to this. If classic passing is missing a wide open receiver 30% of the time, something is wrong with that implementation.
Exactly it feels like the QB missing wide open check downs with CLASSIC PASSING is broken I have yet to see ea say anything about it I did tweet at them, but I didn't feel like waiting so I just switched to skill based passing. I've been playing madden since I was a kid and this is the first year QB's consistently miss WIDE OPEN passes and it coincidently the 2nd year after they made skill based passing. Idk maybe its not on purpose, but I think when GUNSLINGER comes around classic might be viable again.
Then your post above must be correct - these misses are the norm. Because I'm missing wide open 5 yard passes from Tua who has 86 short accuracy. It says poor accuracy and I can tell my meter timing was not good.
Hell half the time mine says perfect accuracy and its still no where near them. I just got the token to make bryce a 86 and maybe its just a string of good luck or its placebo effect but its the only card that hasn't done that for me so far. His 84 was terrible about it, so maybe it is just a good roll I'm on with him.
Was definitely just on a roll with the 86 bryce. He has done nothing but miss passes the last 3 games. Some of them don't have a explanation, like I had a curl sitting there as a check down, was just standing there, so I make my reads and nothings there so I go to dump it down to the curl who had at least a 8 yard buffer in any direction and bryce threw it legit like 15 yards past him and maybe 10 yards horizontally away from the curl. Perfect accuracy, out of reach is what it said.
Yes and no. Skill based passing to me is all about "covered" receivers and being able to dot the ball exactly where you want it to make a previously contested ball catchable. I agree that this should be user input / skill driven, and classic passing shouldn't mimic this ability.
HOWEVER, to the point of this post, whether it's classic passing or skill passing, hitting a wide open receiver or an RB on a check down should have zero percent correlation to this. If classic passing is missing a wide open receiver 30% of the time, something is wrong with that implementation.
Exactly it feels like the QB missing wide open check downs with CLASSIC PASSING is broken I have yet to see ea say anything about it I did tweet at them, but I didn't feel like waiting so I just switched to skill based passing. I've been playing madden since I was a kid and this is the first year QB's consistently miss WIDE OPEN passes and it coincidently the 2nd year after they made skill based passing. Idk maybe its not on purpose, but I think when GUNSLINGER comes around classic might be viable again.
Idk man maybe I'm wrong then. I thought skill based passing had to with the meter.
There is no penalty for the meter, only a bonus if its timed right.
Then your post above must be correct - these misses are the norm. Because I'm missing wide open 5 yard passes from Tua who has 86 short accuracy. It says poor accuracy and I can tell my meter timing was not good.
Hell half the time mine says perfect accuracy and its still no where near them. I just got the token to make bryce a 86 and maybe its just a string of good luck or its placebo effect but its the only card that hasn't done that for me so far. His 84 was terrible about it, so maybe it is just a good roll I'm on with him.
Was definitely just on a roll with the 86 bryce. He has done nothing but miss passes the last 3 games. Some of them don't have a explanation, like I had a curl sitting there as a check down, was just standing there, so I make my reads and nothings there so I go to dump it down to the curl who had at least a 8 yard buffer in any direction and bryce threw it legit like 15 yards past him and maybe 10 yards horizontally away from the curl. Perfect accuracy, out of reach is what it said.