There really shouldn't even be a poll for this. It should be Barr. End of story. Ultimate user card. Speed, height, balanced rush/coverage, and tip drill. Only flaw is I wish EA would've let the man upgrade Barr's strength. Thankfully he was my NAT UT after 10 UT Grahams. Even if he wasn't NAT, I wouldn't trade him for all the other cards in MUT combined. EA hooked me by making my first free pro pack pull a Barr, and I only ripped the free ones that came with my console with no intent on joining MUT.
Gushing for former classmate aside, I will say I like putting BB Von in sometimes on Dime DL packages. But I've tried em all (Taylor, Greene, Watt, Hendricks, even borrowed a MCS Houston). None hold a candle to Barr. Though I would like to try out a 98 Mack.